Add Film | Edit Film
Search for:  

Film Reviews 
 
Reviewer Comments For
Winged Migration
Description:
Winged Migration
click to zoom

The cameras of Jacques Perrin fly with migratory birds: geese, storks, cranes. The film begins with spring in North America and the migration to the Arctic; the flight is a community event for each species. Once in the Arctic, it's family time: courtship, nests, eggs, fledglings, and first flight. Chicks must soon fly south. Bad weather, hunters, and pollution take their toll. Then, the cameras go south of the Equator; Antarctica is the summer destination. The search for food, good weather, and a place to hatch young takes this annual cycle of stamina across continents and oceans. There is a spare narration and a few titles; for the most part it's visual, a bird's eye view.

Release Date: 2001

Director: Perrin and Cluzaud

Buy this film at Amazon.com
Submit a Review  |  23 Hits  |  Visit Website
Average Rating based on 2 Reviews
Overall Rating 
3.50/53.50/53.50/53.50/53.50/5
 (3.50)
Production Quality 
4.50/54.50/54.50/54.50/54.50/5
 (4.50)
Entertainment Value 
3.00/53.00/53.00/53.00/53.00/5
 (3.00)
Educational Value 
3.00/53.00/53.00/53.00/53.00/5
 (3.00)

Compared to averages for similar items
Overall Rating 
3.80/53.80/53.80/53.80/53.80/5
 (3.80)
Production Quality 
4.60/54.60/54.60/54.60/54.60/5
 (4.60)
Entertainment Value 
3.20/53.20/53.20/53.20/53.20/5
 (3.20)
Educational Value 
3.60/53.60/53.60/53.60/53.60/5
 (3.60)

Last Update: November 14, 2006
  Tell a friend      Get review alerts
Displaying Reviews: 1 - 2
Sort By:  
(Review ID: 13)
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
 
Beautiful and well-filmed but not very informative, October 13, 2006
Reviewer: xarizmu from Kansas
    
xarizmu saw things this way
Overall Rating  
2.00/52.00/52.00/52.00/52.00/5
 (2)
Production Quality  
4.00/54.00/54.00/54.00/54.00/5
 (4)
Entertainment Value  
2.00/52.00/52.00/52.00/52.00/5
 (2)
Educational Value  
1.00/51.00/51.00/51.00/51.00/5
 (1)


Pros: Excellent cinematography and nice music.
Cons: Very little factual information.

I enjoy documentaries and grew up on nature shows, so I expect to learn from a documentary, which is perhaps why this film was very boring. The only education in this film is visual, and without a factual informational counterpart, it was difficult to become invested. The birds are beautiful, the shots are awesome, and the overall idea of long distance migration is amazing, but I already knew that going into the film. I expected to learn more about it than "birds fly south for the winter, and sometimes they die along the way."

So if you want to watch awe-inspiring beautiful sequences of flying birds, watch this movie, but don't expect to learn very much factual information.
 
report this review
Was this review helpful to you?   
    
 
(Review ID: 8)
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
 
See Birds Like the Birds do, September 29, 2006
Reviewer: WideAngle
    
WideAngle saw things this way
Overall Rating  
5.00/55.00/55.00/55.00/55.00/5
 (5)
Production Quality  
5.00/55.00/55.00/55.00/55.00/5
 (5)
Entertainment Value  
4.00/54.00/54.00/54.00/54.00/5
 (4)
Educational Value  
5.00/55.00/55.00/55.00/55.00/5
 (5)


Pros: Fantastic Film
Cons: NONE!

I'm not a bird watcher and was pressured into watching this film. It was one of the best overall films of the year for me. Amazing doesn't cut it. The making-of was a must see also.
 
report this review
Was this review helpful to you?   
    
 
Powered by Red Queen v1.05 for documentaryfilms.net
Top of Page